Have you ever wondered how some products become runaway successes while others never quite find their footing? Often, the difference between successful products and failed ones comes down to product testing. Product testing in market research helps brands launch new products with an anticipated understanding of how their target audience will react.
This guide will provide an in-depth exploration of product testing, starting with what it is, how to leverage it effectively, and a step-by-step approach to follow.
Table of Contents:
- What is product testing in market research?
- Advanced methods for effective product testing
- Step-by-step approach to the product testing process
- Uncovering consumer insights through product testing
- Balancing quantitative and qualitative data in product testing
- Overcoming common product testing challenges
- Automating product testing for faster insights
- Maximizing the value of your product testing efforts using quantilope
What is product testing in market research?
Product testing is the process of evaluating a product idea, product prototypes, or even existing products among current or potential customers. It involves gathering customer feedback throughout the product development process to inform crucial decisions – such as changing certain product features or pivoting your messaging strategy/positioning.
Product testing goes beyond simply asking if consumers like something; it’s a market research methodology designed to uncover valuable insights into how consumers perceive, use, and ultimately feel about a product. Whether you're in the early stages of refining a product concept or preparing for an official product launch, understanding how your target market feels about your offering is key for success; often, product flops are a result of not product testing for consumer perceptions prior to launch. Think of product testing as a vital feedback loop that helps ensure you're on the right track to creating a successful product.
Back to Table of Contents
Advanced methods for effective product testing
There are a variety of methods brands can use to gain a deeper understanding of consumer reactions toward their products.
Quantitative research involves a large sample size and focuses on collecting numerical data through structured online questionnaires. This type of data helps brands measure customer satisfaction, purchase intent, and perceived product performance. Within a quantitative research study, brands can choose from a number of advanced methodologies to dive deeper into consumer insights. These are methods like A/B testing where respondents evaluate one product at a time (sequential monadic), MaxDiff analysis where respondents make tradeoff decisions for a long list of product features, or Choice-Based Conjoint where respondents are shown entire product offerings, each with different elements - such as price, size, material, etc., choosing the overall offer they find most appealing.
Additionally, brands can leverage qualitative research in their product testing approach. qualitative methods often involving small focus groups or in-depth interviews where a moderator will uncover the "why" behind consumer feedback. For example, quantilope’s inColor solution captures video feedback to research prompts like why they like or dislike a product, or how the product could be improved. quantilope’s qualitative approach automatically analyzes feedback for sentiments, keywords, and facial expressions. This type of data provides rich, descriptive feedback related to user experience, emotional response, and unmet customers’ needs – often in more depth than you'd get from a quantitative survey alone.
In-home usage tests (ihuts) are another qualitative research approach where participants will test products in their natural environment (i.e. their homes), providing realistic feedback on functionality and usability over time. Similarly, central location tests (clts) offer a controlled environment where researchers can observe participants’ direct interactions with a product.
Each methodology – quantitative, qualitative, or a mix of both – offers unique advantages and actionable insights. Curious to learn more about advanced methods? Explore all of quantilope’s advanced methods and how to use them.
Back to Table of Contents
Step-by-step approach to the product testing process
A thoughtful and carefully executed product testing process is key for obtaining reliable and actionable insights. Below is an overview of the key steps typically involved:
Setting clear objectives and planning your process
Before any testing begins, start by defining what you want to learn about your product. Are you trying to gauge initial consumer reactions to a new product; identify opportunities for optimizing an existing product; or understand how your product compares to the competition (i.e. benchmark research)? Clearly defined objectives will guide the rest of your product research efforts and ensure you collect relevant data. Careful planning also helps determine your budget, timeline, and the resources required.
Selecting the right testing methodology
The types of product testing you use will depend on your research objectives and the stage of product development. For early-stage concept testing, you might use qualitative research to explore initial reactions to a product idea and ensure that it’s a fit for the market. Later, as you develop prototypes, quantitative methods can provide measurable feedback on functionality, user experience, and preference to help fine tune your offering. Alternatively, you might first capture quantitative data and then decide to further explore a certain insight with a qualitative focus group or interview.
To choose the right methodology, consider what your most pressing research questions are and what kind of data will best help you answer them. You can always iterate or add to your research approach later on.
Recruiting representative test participants
The quality of your insights heavily depends on the quality of your respondents. Recruit participants who accurately represent your target audience or potential customers. This often involves considering demographic factors, usage habits, and attitudes relevant to your product categories (e.g. making sure people buy body wash at a certain frequency to qualify them for a body wash study).
Third-party panel providers can help you capture relevant, high-quality sample by sourcing from their pre-vetted pool of participants for a vast array of research criteria (even particularly niche audiences).
Collecting and analyzing data
Once your product testing is complete (or, once you’ve begun capturing data if using a platform that offers real-time access), you can begin to analyze your product insights. For quantitative studies, this involves statistical analysis to identify trends and significant findings. For qualitative research, this step involves careful interpretation of open-ended responses and observations to uncover key themes and insights. Many platform and tools leverage AI to streamline the analysis process, such as quantilope’s AI co-pilot, quinn!
Translating insights into action
The final and most important step to product testing is to translate your findings into actionable product strategies. During this step, consider how you might refine product features based on feedback, such as adjusting your marketing messages to better resonate with your target market, or even making fundamental changes to your product concept. The goal of product testing isn't just to gather data; it's to drive informed decisions that lead to a successful product launch.
Back to Table of Contents
Uncovering consumer insights through product testing
Product testing is a powerful tool for gaining a deep understanding of your consumers. That is, if you know how to uncover the right product insights that lead to strategic business decisions.
Below we’ll explore how to actually uncover and interpret consumer insights from your product testing research.
Understanding customer needs and pain points
Through thoughtful quantitative questioning and/or qualitative observation, product testing can reveal unmet needs and existing pain points that you can act on. Quantitative research methods are great at uncovering these underlying motivations and frustrations, providing context to standard usage and attitude metrics. Implicit Association Testing is one example of an advanced method that goes beyond basic data to capture underlying, subconscious consumer pain points, needs, and preferences.
Identifying product strengths and weaknesses
Whether you're testing a new product or evaluating existing products, understanding strengths and weaknesses from consumers' perspectives is key to sustained or future success. Be sure to include questions that highlight where your product stands out or falls behind. MaxDiff analysis is one advanced method that helps prioritize these elements through forced respondent tradeoff decisions.
Optimizing user experience
A positive user experience dictates whether or not a product will be a success or a flop (and if consumers will spread positive word of mouth about your product to others). Usability testing, a specific type of product testing, focuses specifically on how easy and enjoyable a product is to use. Product testers can highlight aspects they love, features they find confusing, or areas where the product/prototype falls short of their expectations. This direct customer feedback fuels later product optimization to enhance customer satisfaction.
Back to Table of Contents
Balancing quantitative and qualitative data in product testing
Relying solely on quantitative data can provide helpful insights through statistical significance but may lack the depth of understanding the "why" behind the numbers. Conversely, qualitative research offers rich insights but may not be generalizable to a larger population. The most effective product testing often involves a balanced approach of methodologies, using both quantitative and qualitative research to gain a holistic view of consumer perceptions.
Brands can leverage both by starting with qualitative focus groups to explore initial reactions to a product idea, followed by a quantitative survey with a larger sample size to measure purchase intent and customer satisfaction. Or, brands might opt to start out with quantitative research to capture quantifiable metrics, and then further explore key insights through qualitative focus groups.
Back to Table of Contents
Overcoming common product testing challenges
Even with careful planning, product testing can present some challenges. Below are a few to keep an eye out for so you know how to navigate if they arise.
Sample size
One common challenge is ensuring you recruit a sample size that is truly representative of an entire population. Capturing insights among the wrong audience can lead to decisions that don’t positively influence those actually shopping for your product. Using a panel provider is a great way to capture precisely the audience you need, based on your survey’s screening criteria.
Cost
Another challenge can be cost. Finding cost-effective solutions that still deliver complex, sophisticated results can be a challenge. Many platforms and research providers offer sophisticated insights but at a very high price tag. Others offer cheap, quick solutions that lack depth. Look for a platform that doesn’t sacrifice quality or speed of insights at the sake of cost.
Bias
Survey bias is another common concern for product researchers, ensuring they capture unbiased feedback and can mitigate what’s known as the Hawthorne effect – where participants alter their behavior because they know they're being observed. To minimize this risk, leverage robust methodology that captures authentic consumer feedback (like Implicit testing or a MaxDiff analysis). For qualitative product research, make sure your questions are broad enough where they don't lead a response one way or the other.
Back to Table of Contents
Automating product testing for faster insights
As mentioned above, product testing can come with some challenges. Fortunately, automated research platforms remove a lot of those challenges by capturing insights quickly, at an affordable rate, and with advanced methodologies and guardrails in place to ensure high-quality responses.
Automating your product testing process, from questionnaire design and distribution to data analysis and reporting, can significantly accelerate the timeline for gathering valuable insights. Automation also removes some of the potential for human researcher bias.
Back to Table of Contents
Maximizing the value of your product testing efforts using quantilope
quantilope’s Consumer Intelligence Platform empowers researchers of any background or skillset to streamline their product testing efforts across the entire product lifecycle. From early-stage concept testing to evaluating product performance post-product launch, quantilope’s platform ensures high quality customer feedback to fuel any new product development process.
Using quantilope’s end-to-end automation tools, product researchers can craft online questionnaires instantly through customizable, pre-built survey templates or through drag-and-drop modules. They’ll select any number of questions or advanced methods from quantilope’s question library (with the ability to create entirely custom questions as well), then select their panel provider of choice (or connect their own sample), click ‘launch’, and watch respondent data populate charts and dashboards in real-time. Researchers looking to incorporate qualitative product feedback can set up their inColor study just as easily, providing a list of questions to ask respondents and receive video replies back. These insights are then automatically analyzed for things like sentiment, emotion, and even body language.
quantilope’s integrated AI co-pilot, quinn, makes the product testing process even more efficient by offering anytime guidance and inspiration throughout the entire research cycle. From survey suggestions to automated chart headlines and custom question feedback (through the platform’s pop-ip chat window), quinn is a collaborative extension of any research team.
By leveraging quantilope, you can optimize your product testing process, gain a deeper understanding of your potential customers, and ultimately increase your chances of launching a successful product.
